How “Family Annihilators” Think

In this in-depth analysis, experts delve into the mindset of individuals who commit unthinkable crimes, exploring how “family annihilators” think and what motivates these terrible killers. Understanding the psychological underpinnings of such actions can provide valuable insights into the prevention and intervention of such tragic events.

At the Celebration, Florida planned neighborhood bougainvillea vines trail along white picket fences and open window shutters. The village, which the Walt Disney Corporation created in the 1990s, has broad front porches just steps from tree-shaded sidewalks that encourage dialogue with neighbors and passersby. The Todt family, originally from Connecticut, had resided there for two years in a neat Neo-Colonial on Reserve Place.

Anthony Todt was discovered in his bedroom on January 13, 2020, surrounded by the blanket-wrapped and decomposing remains of his wife, three children, and the family dog, after a relative requested a welfare check. According to the Orlando medical examiner, Megan Todt, 42, and the couple’s children Alek, 13, Tyler, 11, and Zoe, 4, died from “unspecified homicidal violence” and “diphenhydramine poisoning,” also known as Benadryl.

According to investigators, Mr. Todt was severely delinquent on rent and other payments, and federal officials were investigating his Connecticut physical therapy practice. He later admitted to the murders. He was convicted of four charges of first-degree murder and one count of animal cruelty in April 2022. He was given four consecutive sentences of life without parole.

Mr. Todt joined the ranks of “family annihilators,” or those who conduct familicide, the most extreme form of domestic violence. According to a 2015 research published in the Journal of Forensic Sciences, familicide occurs an average of 23 times per year in the United States.

The ubiquity and immorality of familicide have elevated it to the realm of popular culture: For example, in September 2020, Netflix debuted American Murder: The Family Next Door. The documentary examines the circumstances behind Chris Watts’ infamous 2018 murder of his 34-year-old wife and their two young girls in Frederick, Colorado, as well as the subsequent investigation.

While the specifics of family annihilators may differ, according to specialists, some commonalities motivate them to commit horrific deeds.

Features of Typical Family Destroyers

Neil Websdale, Ph.D., director of the Family Violence Institute at Northern Arizona University, director of the National Domestic Violence Fatality Review Initiative, and author of Familicidal Hearts: The Emotional Styles of 211 Killers, estimates that approximately 95% of familicide perpetrators are male.

In her analysis of 408 homicide-suicide cases, Johns Hopkins University professor Jacqueline C. Campbell, Ph.D., discovered that 91% of perpetrators were male. Domestic violence histories were prevalent. Dr. Campbell’s 12-city examination of similar instances revealed that 70% of them involved “intimate-partner violence,” although only 25% of earlier domestic violence was documented in arrest records. Typically, this evidence was uncovered through interviews with the victim’s family and acquaintances.

Dr. Websdale concurs that domestic violence is a risk factor, stating that approximately fifty percent of such cases have a history of it. He describes one-quarter to one-third of them as ‘civil/respectable’ respectable people who’ve fallen from grace, without a history of domestic violence,’ whilst the remainder contain components of both categories.

Additional characteristics? According to Dr. Campbell’s research, these murderers are typically non-Hispanic white males with access to a firearm, a stepchild at home, or an estranged relationship. Incongruously, past criminal history is not a reliable indicator because they rarely have a criminal record.

What Motivates Those Who Destroy Families?

The question remains as to what motivates these individuals to murder their relatives. According to experts, family annihilators typically fall into one of many categories.

Infuriated by the family separation.

According to a survey of British murder cases, the most common reason males murder their families is familial dissolution. According to studies, these murderers frequently hold their partners accountable for the family’s results. A divorce could be imminent, or their children could be removed from them.

A need for authority.

According to Dr. Websdale, perpetrators of familicide may have a variety of motives, but power is typically a major factor. ′′For the enraged, forceful killers, who are likely the majority,′′ he observes, ′′we’re talking about a need to assert their authority and power in relationships. They see their control to be waning; they are humiliated and enraged by who they are and what their partners have done. They are vindictive.

Methodologically, when “intimate violent terrorists” attack their families, it is frequently an attempt to reassert control over their relationships.

This lack of control is typical due to the perception that one is losing his manhood. These murderers, who are typically heterosexual, hold stereotyped views about the family dynamic.

Characterized by a personality problem.

Chris Watts was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of release in November 2018 for the August 2018 murders of his pregnant wife, Shanann Watts, and his three- and four-year-old children, Celeste and Bella. Authorities asserted that Watts’ “desire for a fresh start” was a motivating factor in his criminal activity. Watts, who was 33 at the time of the murders, was dating another woman.

The Netflix crime documentary examines the Watts case, which New York City clinical psychologist N. G. Berrill, Ph.D., deems indicative of a psychopathic, antisocial personality. Dr. Berrill, who is also the director of New York Forensic and a forensic investigator who specializes in evaluating violent individuals, describes this individual as “weary of their marriage, bored of the responsibility of having children, meets someone new, and is possibly not too intelligent.”

Dr. Berrill states, ‘We’ve seen these cases countless times’ It seems crazy, but [these killers] feel that if they kill their family and use deception to make it appear as if someone else did it, they will be relieved of what they perceive to be an awful burden.

Consider “psychopathic, selfish motives” that are motivated purely by self-interest. Dr. Berrill distinguishes these killers from people who have suffered a psychotic break or other mental impairment by stating, “From a clinical standpoint, none of it is explicable or justifiable, but it’s also the most horrific and terrifying because they know exactly what they’re doing.”

Incapable of handling personal failure.

In certain circumstances, husbands may not have been possessive or domineering; rather, they have undergone significant social or economic upheavals. This is known as an unusual familicide. It appears that this is the situation with the Todt family.

Right before Christmas in 2019, a Florida court received an eviction notice for the Todts’ residence. Records indicate the couple signed a one-year lease in May 2019 and missed more than $4,000 in rent payments in December. According to the Sheriff’s office, Mr. Todt worked as a physical therapist Monday through Friday at his Connecticut firm, Performance Edge Sports, and traveled to Florida on weekends to spend time with his family. In January 2020, federal officials notified the Osceola County Sheriff’s Office of an inquiry involving Mr. Todt and his company.

According to Dr. Websdale, catastrophic news such as this frequently portends familicide among individuals who are not known offenders of domestic abuse. “When there is no history of violence, you are dealing with repressed, overcontrolled, and frequently sad persons,” he says. “It’s a looming calamity in their lives, such as a foreclosure, inability to provide, or saving their children from poverty. There can be various factors, but there is almost a “misguided altruism” in the sense that they believe they are helping families by killing them.

These murderers typically believe that life without their current way of living would be difficult. Furthermore, according to Dr. Websdale, mixed up with the shame of being unable to provide comes an extraordinary sense of entitlement and narcissism – the entitlement to end life in such a manner.

Meaningful articles you might like: What’s the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), How the American Family is Changing, 20 Weekend Family Activities to Enjoy at Home