### Divorce in the Modern Era: Navigating Child Custody in the Age of Shared Parenting

The Alice Hector–Robert Young divorce case illustrates the profound influence of gendered parenting stereotypes in custody disputes. Should feminists align with a particular side in this complex scenario?

In the wee hours of the night, known as the Hour of the Wolf, when worries and insecurities plague weary minds, I find myself in my daughter’s room. Having returned late from work, I missed tucking her into bed. As I gently brush the hair from her face and plant a kiss on her warm, sweet-smelling forehead, I can’t help but wonder if Robert Young is experiencing a similar moment, filled with urgency and the fear of impending separation. Is Alice Hector, his ex-wife, also awake, gazing into her daughters’ vacant rooms, her stomach tied in knots?

This sentiment, originally featured in the June/July 1999 edition of Ms. magazine, encapsulates the emotional turmoil surrounding this case.

The heart of the matter lies in the custody battle that Young and Hector are entangled in, where their daily interactions with their 10 and 13-year-old daughters hang in the balance. Hector, a former partner at a prestigious Miami law firm turned independent practitioner, lost custody of their daughters in June 1998. A trio of male judges overturned a prior ruling that favored Hector, citing her demanding work schedule as a hindrance to her role as the primary caregiver. The custody was awarded to Young, the girls’ father, who transitioned from a stay-at-home dad to a job with more flexible hours. Hector contested the decision, and the case remains pending.

Young’s proactive involvement in his daughters’ lives, from initiating a Brownie troop for the younger one to coaching the elder one’s soccer team, contrasts with Hector’s limitations due to her professional commitments. Despite Hector’s efforts to prioritize her children, dedicating her weekends to them and being available during sickness, the court favored Young’s increased availability for childcare.

Florida’s legal stance on custody leans away from joint arrangements, emphasizing a primary residence for the children while both parents maintain active roles. The initial agreement for shared residence during the divorce settlement negotiations intensified the competition for custody between Hector and Young.

The case unravels deep-seated biases and stereotypes. Hector’s struggle to balance her legal career and motherhood echoes the societal struggle to dissociate masculinity from breadwinning. The court’s inclination towards the primary caregiver, often assumed to be the mother, underscores prevailing gender norms.

The narrative challenges feminists to navigate a nuanced terrain. While advocating for gender equality and recognizing the importance of the primary caretaker, the case presents a dilemma. Should feminists rally behind Hector, a working mother challenging stereotypes, or acknowledge Young’s commitment as a father defying traditional roles?

The broader implications of this custody battle extend beyond the personal realm, shedding light on systemic issues. The need for family-friendly work environments and the reevaluation of overwork culture emerge as critical themes.

Amidst the fervor of gender equity advocacy, the case of Hector and Young serves as a poignant reminder of the intricate layers of societal expectations and legal biases that cloud custody decisions. As feminists grapple with these complexities, the quest for true gender parity faces formidable challenges.

Stay tuned for more thought-provoking insights:

The landscape of U.S. democracy stands at a critical juncture, grappling with issues ranging from reproductive rights and pay equity to maternal health disparities and transgender rights. The imperative to address these crises to ensure equitable political representation looms large. As Ms. continues its legacy of feminist journalism, your support becomes paramount. Join us in championing equality and justice for the next 50 years by contributing to Ms. today. Your contribution, no matter the amount, fuels our mission and amplifies feminist voices across platforms. Receive exclusive access to our publications, updates, and events by becoming a part of the Ms. community. Your dedication and passion drive our commitment to a more inclusive future.